Marketing Yourself · 8 min read

Building a newsletter that readers actually open

The only audience you own. How to start one from nothing, what to put in it, and how often to send.

Of everything an author can do to find readers, an email list is the one with the best returns and the least glamour. Social platforms change their algorithms, restrict reach, and occasionally disappear. An email list is a direct line to people who have already said they want to hear from you, and it moves with you.

Start before you have anything to sell

The most common mistake is waiting until the book is out. A list needs time to grow, and the period before publication — when you are talking about the book most — is when people are most inclined to sign up.

You need three things: a sign-up form on your website, a reason to sign up, and somewhere for the addresses to go. That is genuinely all.

Give a real reason

"Sign up for my newsletter" converts poorly, because it describes what you get. Tell the reader what they get and be specific:

  • "Be first to know when the next book has a release date."
  • "A free short story set between books two and three."
  • "The first chapter, now, before it is published anywhere."

A bonus story is the strongest offer in fiction, because it self-selects: the only people who want it are people who like your writing. That is a far better list than one built on a prize draw.

Put the form where people already are

On your home page above the fold, at the end of every book page, and — the one most authors miss — in the back of the book itself. A reader who has just finished your novel is at their single most receptive moment. One line and a link on the last page will out-perform months of social media.

What to actually send

The failure mode is a newsletter that is only ever "buy my book". People unsubscribe from advertising and stay for a person. A workable mix:

  • Something behind the scenes. Where an idea came from, a place that became a setting, a detail you had to research and got wrong first.
  • Something useful. Recommend three books you loved. Readers of your genre want to be told what to read next, and generosity is remembered.
  • Something human. Short, and genuinely yours. This is what makes it a letter rather than a circular.
  • Then the news. Release dates, signings, where to buy. At the end, once, clearly.

Write to one person. "Hello everyone" reads like a broadcast; "I have been meaning to tell you about —" reads like a letter, and the open rates follow.

How often

Monthly is a good default. Quarterly works if your news is genuinely seasonal. Less often than that and people forget who you are and report you as spam — which damages your delivery to everyone else.

Consistency matters more than frequency. A short, reliable monthly note beats a long, brilliant one that arrives twice a year.

The legal minimum

Wherever you are, three rules are effectively universal, and worth following regardless of jurisdiction:

  • Only email people who asked. Never add someone because you have their address. A pre-ticked box is not consent.
  • Every email needs a working one-click unsubscribe, honoured promptly.
  • Include a real postal address in the footer. A PO box is fine, and is what most authors use.

Use a proper email service rather than the BCC field of your own mail account. It handles the unsubscribes, the address, and the deliverability, and sending bulk mail from a personal account is a reliable way to get that account limited.

Measure the two numbers that matter

Open rate tells you whether your subject lines work. Click rate tells you whether the content does. Everything else is decoration. If opens are healthy and clicks are not, you are writing pleasant emails with no reason to act; if opens are poor, rewrite the subject lines before you touch anything else.

Small is fine

Two hundred people who open your emails and buy your books are worth vastly more than five thousand followers who scrolled past you. Do not be discouraged by the size of the number early on — a list grows with every book, and it is the one asset in your writing career that compounds.

Written by Carol Light. Shared here with permission — read it at its original home.

Follow the series

News from the writing desk, and word the moment there is a publication date.

More on Marketing Yourself